MysticShinHanKu's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Link is Ready For Action!]

meh submission

The animation was meh, not a lot to it. The art wasn't too impressive - seen better seen worse. You lost points for creativity since you took the ideas from a VGcats comic. The voice acting for Navi wasn't great, and was unnecessary. It would've been cooler and more nostalgic for OoT players to just here her say "Look" or "Hey" and then show a dialogue box. The joke was killed because as soon as the fire caught and you heard the tree crumbling, you already knew what the joke would be. If it had a quicker pace you could have surprised the audience and got a better laugh.

Overall, a fine submission, but not that great.

[Dark Knight Interrogation]

kinda weak :/

I was excited when I saw that Hans and Ego were in a Dark Knight spoof, but I was most disappointed :(

The script itself had no jokes. I'm not sure of the "idea" you thought of... you just sort of quoted the movie, and then said some other stuff that weren't really jokes. Ego's Batman was alright, Hans' Gordon was fine, but the Joker was just plain awful. You should have done some actual casting. I understand if you're a big fan and you want to play the Joker, but you should recognize whether or not you can do a good impression. There are several VA's on newgrounds that do some great Joker impressions.

I just didn't see any effort to sound or act like the Joker. The lip smacking was completely out of character - he does just smack his lips, he's bothered by his scars.

The animation was alright - I really liked the look of the Joker and some of the fbf looked very cool. Batman, while kinda funny, didn't look too great - I think you could have made some changes to his look while keeping him funny looking.

It was an alright submission, but having Hans and Ego in it definitely helped your score, sorry :/

[Flecko's Halloween]

awesome stuff

The art and animation were great. The beginning walking sequence was a little long, but the background was entertaining. The fight scene was extremely well animated. that was great. Great fight, great concept, everything was awesome.

the only critique I had were the voices. Igor's voice peaked a lot in his mic, so I'd recommend having someone with higher quality. And I can't exactly critique Flecko as well since you are him... but frankly, your delivery is extremely bland for him. Even the "ENOUGH" part was kinda bland. He just sounded so low and boring for such a cartoony character.

Nice job, you are an awesome animator.

[AwesomeShock]

Great job!

This was loads of fun to work with you on. Sad some parts got cut, but it was totally awesome. I hope to work with you again - thanks for crediting me and letting me work with you!

I had lots of fun. Ugh ma gawd!

[Pincusion Companion]

great stuff

I enjoyed this a lot. The music was a wonderful choice.

The frame by frame was great. Towards the end I was getting a little confused who was who but that's ok. It was great. Doesn't it take a while to draw all those frames of all that combat? Good job.

[Megaman - Rockin in paper]

great stop animation!

great job! Looked great, well thought out, and nice music sync.

What did you do in After Effects?

Totsugeki responds:

Simply everything, except the preloader and the credits ;D

[A ComiX Halloween!]

a solid animation

I really liked the look of everything. The animation was done well - you use tweens in a way that doesn't bother which is good. Some of the jokes were funny, others weren't, but overall I liked it.

The voice acting quality was pretty good, the performance it self was good, but I didn't like how you did all or most of the voices yourself. A lot of people can pull that off, but having two main characters who are just regular teenagers voiced by the same guy is very noticeable. It distracted me since I could immediately tell they were both done by the same person, and one of them had a strange more open chest voice, and the other had a higher throaty voice.

They just seemed like strange choices for voices - not really cartoony, not really realistic, just a little off to me. That's just me.

Nice job.

DAGamesOfficial responds:

thanx man. well problem is that I love doing both gordon and ian. nobody else could do it, cus then it just wudnt BE gordon or Ian. so cant change the voices Im afraid. if I changed them now, people would think "wtf? thats not what ian and gordon sound like!" so yeah sorry man xP

but in any case, glad ya liked the cartoon :D

[GunChest Episode 01_02]

I love this!

Dude, you are truly amazing, this is awesome! I love the 3D and the fighting and the sound is great. All of the action is top notch, perfect, actually...

But wow if the voice acting isn't bad... Black needs a new voice actor bad, he's not as deep and gruff as he's pretending to be. It just isn't working for him in my opinion. Even Gunchest's voice isn't great, but he's probably the best one.

Some of the script could be changed as well such as the part when Black said it wasn't a great present - that was a tad cliche lol.

But all in all it gave a great vibe, but the voice acting reminded me of the bad acting from some bad anime or power rangers. That area needs more.

Everything else is just perfect.